No, bringing Karzai to power was not part of the deal. No Afghansitans boundaries were not stable during the past 250 years. And yes Afghansitan is an artificial state with all its boundries drawn by the British and Russians!!!
you proved it by talking of our brother tribes as they have 5 thousand year common history , you talk about majority and minority , north and south , sonni and shia etc. For the same reason { DIVID AND RULE ] Mr.Barfield.
This is the formula of imperialism, division and rule, people are not fighting to each other , they are fighting against you imperialist occupiers USA and NATO
Thomas Barfield is saying :Nobody want seperation, now then what is pashtun nationalism; why late pakistani PM zulfikar ali bhutto created taliban with US backup.
Karzai was elected as president not by the minority ethnics of Northern Afghanistan but by international community, because they knew that the Pashtuns who make more than 60% of Afghan population will never accept a tajik or hazara or Uzbek president in their country and this will never end the civil war, so that is why the president should be a pashtun
Never put up an American to even give a lecture on such things. I can't even listen to what he wants to say which may even be smart … Americans should keep silent in next 100 years…
pashtons are the authenticity of Afghanistan and they made this country and non pashtons are all like muslims in India like they live in India but support Pakistan we got the samiliar situation in Afghanistan non pashtons live in Afghanistan but they hate to be called Afghan,they will be pleased if you call them Tajik or Persian,i dont understand if these jerks are not pleased with having Afghan name. then they gotta go to Iran but for sure they are not welcomed there as well, so this means that this jerk tribe just simply prefer to be slave to Iran rather having Afghan name shame on this cheap tribe
Afghanistan is always been a poor country always fight no roads so many mountains very rough place to live no water no food they grow lot of heroin they always fight .they were part of india also thats why buddha was there dont blame on British or any one else admit your fault tell me the time when was Afghanistan a super power .you cant hide truth
That's bullshit, I'm from Afghanistan and I'm separatist. We people of the North, West, and Central who are more than 30 ethnic groups and are Sunni and Shia and don't have any problem together and love each other. We just want the Pashtuns to create their own Pashtunistan and leave us. We are people of Khorasan, learn it if you don't know what it is! We are tired of stone-age Pashtuns who are Taliban and Isis. We don't want our country to turn to pieces but only 2 parts. only 35% of people of Afghanistan are Afghan aka Pashtun. We never want those terrorist stupid Pashtuns of Pakistan join us!
Hazara are the native people of Afghanistan. The British, Iran and Russian and their Alies help to build a terrorist nation of Taliban and isis to punish all ethnicity on this Beautiful Land of peace for the rest of their lives. The plan of these countries are to finish all the Hazaras and the rest of ethnics by killing them in the name of religion and politics, just the way they have done to the native people of Canada, Australia, Russia, America and South America. Thomas Bardfield is terrorist and he's plan is to devide people of Afghanistan and rule them for the rest of their lives. All these countries are terrorists Saudi Arabia, Russia, Iran and UK with it's Allies. Their mission is to finish all other ethnics from this planet and then fight each other so one of their race can remain on this planet Blond hair, yellow skin and blue eyes.
Afghanistan is a nation state the minorities in Afghanistan like uzbek,tajik hazara are immigrants.. like after mongols invasion hazaras settled in Afghanistan and during different Afghan-persian war tajiks settled in Afghanistan
Afghanistan,Pakistan, was the part of India. Invaders took our Land coverted them forcibly. Afghanistan was a Hindu Budhist land. Afgan have South Asian Indian Ancestry who are mixed with the MiddleEast.
Well said but he is wrong on one thing, the Afghan government wants the Pashtunistan area of Pakistan to rejoin with Afghanistan, it doesn't want it to become its own country. Only a few nationalists on the other side want their own country but majority want a loy Afghanistan.
who said that Tajiks Uzbek proud on being afghan we hate from afghan name Afghan mean terror narcotics corruption we can say proudly we are Tajiks the mean problem in Afghanistan is pashtoon they roll the country they are Taliban they are Isis they are burning the schools blowing up the roads destroyed all country they don't live like humans they don't let the others to live like humans always killing the innocent people
Afghanistan had more then 5000 years of history, Even more then 5000y because before that is not written or not noted. Another names in periodes of time but Same people. You know Why Afghans NEVER don't give up? because they are optimist. Afghans fight each other but when a threat has come in to Afghanistan. They always stand together to fight the enemy . Then they don't fight for the ethnic groups. The new generations are more for being United not fighting each other.
this man is speaking out of his ass. he is talking like we had a choice in hamid karzai becoming president. he was put in power by USA. the only problem in afghanistan r pashtuns. the rest of the ethnicity do not have a problem with one another except with pashtuns
Afghanistan has lots of different ethnic groups and different languages but official language of Afghanistan is Pashto and Dari and the national anthem of Afghanistan is in Pashto as well respect from afghan Pashtun
South asia in general im talking about india, pakistan and afghanistan have soo many groups and languages its actually crazy how many there are
JAPAN VS AFGHANISTAN JAPAN AT FOREFRONT OF TECHNOLOGY WHILE AFGHANISTAN SURVIVES ON DONATIONS LAZY PEOPLE
Afghanistan for sure will rise like s phoenix & soon become a progressive prosperous state, people. Thoughts from India.
Its 2018 & the possibility of #FreePashtoonistan independent from Punjabi imperial grip of Pakistan is a question of when not if. #PTM Zindabad !
afghan lion, your rapist grandfatherhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Qcck7WylCk
Only pasthuns have the right to call them self real afghans
And all the people in Afghanistan are not Afghans!!!
No, bringing Karzai to power was not part of the deal. No Afghansitans boundaries were not stable during the past 250 years.
And yes Afghansitan is an artificial state with all its boundries drawn by the British and Russians!!!
you proved it by talking of our brother tribes as they have 5 thousand year common history , you talk about majority and minority , north and south , sonni and shia etc. For the same reason { DIVID AND RULE ] Mr.Barfield.
This is the formula of imperialism, division and rule, people are not fighting to each other , they are fighting against you imperialist occupiers USA and NATO
I have a classmate from Afghanistan ?? and I may let her know what I’ve learned about her culture.
Thomas Barfield is saying :Nobody want seperation, now then what is pashtun nationalism; why late pakistani PM zulfikar ali bhutto created taliban with US backup.
I love Pashtuns so much, I'd die for y'all ?❤️??
Karzai was elected as president not by the minority ethnics of Northern Afghanistan but by international community, because they knew that the Pashtuns who make more than 60% of Afghan population will never accept a tajik or hazara or Uzbek president in their country and this will never end the civil war, so that is why the president should be a pashtun
Pashtuns all the way
PASHTUN=TERRORIST
MAKE HAZARJAT ITS OWN COUNTRY
Tajik Language is Dari
Pashto Language is Pashto
Thank you very much sir
I acknowledge your remarkable opinions and respect your ideas as Afghan
Excellent analysis
Panjshire are 1
Northwest central of Afghanistan We are descendant of Turkic Empires, our ancestors ruled the world for many centuries.
Never put up an American to even give a lecture on such things. I can't even listen to what he wants to say which may even be smart … Americans should keep silent in next 100 years…
pashtons are the authenticity of Afghanistan and they made this country and non pashtons are all like muslims in India like they live in India but support Pakistan we got the samiliar situation in Afghanistan non pashtons live in Afghanistan but they hate to be called Afghan,they will be pleased if you call them Tajik or Persian,i dont understand if these jerks are not pleased with having Afghan name. then they gotta go to Iran but for sure they are not welcomed there as well,
so this means that this jerk tribe just simply prefer to be slave to Iran rather having Afghan name
shame on this cheap tribe
Afghanistan is always been a poor country always fight no roads so many mountains very rough place to live no water no food they grow lot of heroin they always fight .they were part of india also thats why buddha was there dont blame on British or any one else admit your fault tell me the time when was Afghanistan a super power .you cant hide truth
That's bullshit, I'm from Afghanistan and I'm separatist. We people of the North, West, and Central who are more than 30 ethnic groups and are Sunni and Shia and don't have any problem together and love each other. We just want the Pashtuns to create their own Pashtunistan and leave us. We are people of Khorasan, learn it if you don't know what it is! We are tired of stone-age Pashtuns who are Taliban and Isis. We don't want our country to turn to pieces but only 2 parts. only 35% of people of Afghanistan are Afghan aka Pashtun. We never want those terrorist stupid Pashtuns of Pakistan join us!
Brilliant analysis.
Hazara are the native people of Afghanistan. The British, Iran and Russian and their Alies help to build a terrorist nation of Taliban and isis to punish all ethnicity on this Beautiful Land of peace for the rest of their lives. The plan of these countries are to finish all the Hazaras and the rest of ethnics by killing them in the name of religion and politics, just the way they have done to the native people of Canada, Australia, Russia, America and South America. Thomas Bardfield is terrorist and he's plan is to devide people of Afghanistan and rule them for the rest of their lives. All these countries are terrorists Saudi Arabia, Russia, Iran and UK with it's Allies. Their mission is to finish all other ethnics from this planet and then fight each other so one of their race can remain on this planet Blond hair, yellow skin and blue eyes.
Afghans is a national name for pashto speaking people
Afghanistan is a nation state the minorities in Afghanistan like uzbek,tajik hazara are immigrants.. like after mongols invasion hazaras settled in Afghanistan and during different Afghan-persian war tajiks settled in Afghanistan
Hahaha it sounds propaganda video
Afghanistan,Pakistan, was the part of India.
Invaders took our Land coverted them forcibly.
Afghanistan was a Hindu Budhist land.
Afgan have South Asian Indian Ancestry who are mixed with the MiddleEast.
Southern part of Afghan are Baluch’s
Well said but he is wrong on one thing, the Afghan government wants the Pashtunistan area of Pakistan to rejoin with Afghanistan, it doesn't want it to become its own country. Only a few nationalists on the other side want their own country but majority want a loy Afghanistan.
who said that Tajiks Uzbek proud on being afghan we hate from afghan name Afghan mean terror narcotics corruption we can say proudly we are Tajiks the mean problem in Afghanistan is pashtoon they roll the country they are Taliban they are Isis they are burning the schools blowing up the roads destroyed all country they don't live like humans they don't let the others to live like humans always killing the innocent people
Good information
absolutely wrong !
tajik,uzbek,hazara and pashton they all proudly believe they are afghans and nobady has ever said that they want to leave afg
Afghanistan had more then 5000 years of history, Even more then 5000y because before that is not written or not noted. Another names in periodes of time but Same people. You know Why Afghans NEVER don't give up? because they are optimist. Afghans fight each other but when a threat has come in to Afghanistan. They always stand together to fight the enemy . Then they don't fight for the ethnic groups. The new generations are more for being United not fighting each other.
this man is speaking out of his ass.
he is talking like we had a choice in hamid karzai becoming president. he was put in power by USA.
the only problem in afghanistan r pashtuns. the rest of the ethnicity do not have a problem with one another except with pashtuns
ahh Afghanistan was a country since the time of jesus and older was bactria??
Afghanistan has lots of different ethnic groups and different languages but official language of Afghanistan is Pashto and Dari and the national anthem of Afghanistan is in Pashto as well respect from afghan Pashtun